Skip to main content
Floor vote

House vote #37

On Motion to Commit with Instructions

Class Action Fairness Act

Failed Congress 109 · Session 1 Feb 17, 2005 · 1:41 PM EST  S. 5
Raw XML

S. 5: Class Action Fairness Act of 2005

On February 17, 2005 the Motion to Commit with Instructions on S. 5 (Class Action Fairness Act of 2005) failed in the House, 175 to 249.

FAILED
175–249
+74 margin
Democrats
174 22
Republicans
227
Independents
1
Majority threshold YES 175 249 NO
424 members voted · 10 Not Voting Failed by 74 votes
Crossed the aisle 2

Members who voted against their own party's majority position.

Democratic Voted YEA (37 for, 2 against), but 2 members below broke ranks and voted NAY.
 Voted yes 38
Baldwin D Bishop D Cleaver D Clyburn D Costa D Davis D DeGette D DeLauro D Doggett D Green D Hoyer D Kaptur D Larsen D Larson D Lofgren D Lynch D Markey D McCollum D McGovern D Meeks D Moore D Nadler D Neal D Pallone D Pelosi D Sánchez D Sanders I Schakowsky D Schiff D Scott D Sherman D A. Smith D B. Thompson D M. Thompson D Van Hollen D Velázquez D Wasserman Schultz D Waters D
 Voted no 24
Aderholt R Blackburn R Boozman R Calvert R Capito R Carter R Case D Cole R Cuellar D Diaz-Balart R Foxx R Graves R Issa R Lucas R McCaul R Moran R H. Rogers R M. Rogers R Sessions R Simpson R C. Smith R Turner R Wicker R Wilson R
Report a problem